Babel Clash

Who is the better detective: Sherlock Holmes or Batman?—now that is an interesting question. Of course, phrased that way—who is a better detective—I think the answer obviously is Holmes. After all, Holmes relies purely on his own intellect to solve his cases while Batman has a wealth of technology at his fingertips to enhance his abilities.

But if you were to take a slightly different approach to the question and say: “Who is the better crimefighter?” I’d have to give that to Batman. Now, Holmes is clearly excellent in this more broadly-defined category as well, in that he certainly does a lot to fight crime and is quite good at foiling plots and catching wrongdoers and putting hem behind bars. But Batman is a more well-rounded crime fighter in that he can do, well, a lot more fighting. Admittedly, as I’ve said before, Holmes has mad fighting skills too, but in this case I’m sure he’d be outclassed. Batman is a pure fighting machine; he’s just a regular guy and he takes on superpowered villains! (Though of course I could imagine Holmes using his intellect to come up with clever ways of defeating even the worst of Batman’s foes, especially if he had Batman’s gadgets at his disposal.) So, while I’d give the honor of “best crimefighter” to Batman, this was by no means a blowout; in fact, it was a really, really close call.

As for your other question about how I put my anthologies together…that’s a more complicated answer, so I’ll save that for another post. But I will say that no, I haven’t done any comic book-related anthologies as of yet, though I’d love to. You hear that D.C.? You listening Marvel? YOU GUYS—I’M AVAILABLE.

Related posts:

• Holmes vs. the Impossible
  Although Sir Arthur Conan Doyle always had a rational solution for each of Sherlock Holmes’s cases—even the one called “The Case of the Sussex Vampire”—the Victorian/Edwardian age in which Holmes lives feels like the supernatural would be very much at home. It’s funny that Holmes never enountered a case involving...
• Holmes against the supernatural
  Based on what little of the new Holmes movie that we’ve seen in the trailer, it appears as if the supernatural plays some part.  Now, that may all turn out to be smoke & mirrors, but it does look to involve the occult in some way.  So, what’s your preference...
• Sherlock Holmes vs. Captain Kirk
  OK, so Sherlock Holmes has outwitted Gandalf.  Score one for the master detective. Now he’s met his match.  For round 2:  “Who has more luck with the ladies, Sherlock Holmes or Captain Kirk?” ...
• Anthology vs. Anthology, or Burns vs. Adams
  After our first two questions, it seems as though Mr. Burns is intent on having me pit my anthologies against each other. (He’s probably steepling his fingers together as he hisses “Excellent” to himself.) The reason we’ve been talking about Sherlock Holmes is not only because of the Guy Ritchie...
• Kirk vs. Holmes
  Morgan asked: “Who has more luck with the ladies, Sherlock Holmes or Captain Kirk?” The answer is elementary once again, my dear Morgan, though this time it is obviously NOT Holmes. James Tiberius Kirk, that great, golden Lothario of the spaceways, is practically as well-known for his sexual prowess as...