Our next topic is…
by morgan on Dec.08, 2009, under John Joseph Adams
Welcome to John Joseph Adams.
In honor of his anthology, the Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, and the new Holmes film opening Christmas Day, Babel Clash asks the hard questions. We’ll begin with a real puzzler: “Who’s smarter, Sherlock Holmes or Gandalf?”

Related posts:
- And our next guest is… Steve, thank you once again for all of the great posts and for spending time with us on Babel Clash. Good luck with Elegy Beach and other books to come. I’m looking forward to seeing what you try next. Our next guest is John Joseph Adams, highly regarded editor and...
- Sherlock Holmes vs. Captain Kirk OK, so Sherlock Holmes has outwitted Gandalf. Score one for the master detective. Now he’s met his match. For round 2: “Who has more luck with the ladies, Sherlock Holmes or Captain Kirk?” ...
- Holmes against the supernatural Based on what little of the new Holmes movie that we’ve seen in the trailer, it appears as if the supernatural plays some part. Now, that may all turn out to be smoke & mirrors, but it does look to involve the occult in some way. So, what’s your preference...
- M for Moriarty How quickly you’ve unveiled my master plan. Little did you know that “Morgan” was a carefully crafted moniker to hide my true identity, that of Professor Moriarty, Sherlock Holmses’ arch-nemesis. OK, I’ll cut the megalomaniacal laughter now. Have you written any comic book anthologies? I was very tempted to ask...
- Collections John, With the focus on Lightspeed, will we continue to see more of your anthologies? From Wastelands to the Improbable Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, you’ve edited some of the bestselling and most noteworthy collections that we’ve seen in awhile. If more are forthcoming, can you offer any hints to the...

December 8th, 2009 on 1:11 pm
I’ve got to go with Gandalf. While they’re both brilliant, Sherlock’s only had one standard human lifetime to gather information. Gandalf has been alive for at least 5k years!