Babel Clash

Ooh, ooh, a subject on which we can agree (no, not that I look like a male prostitute from Fable) but that the death of Aerith in FF7 was a great moment.  I walked around open-mouthed for hours.  Then I cried, and cried, and cried.  Then the denial.  Then the anger.  Then I cried, and I cried, and I cried again.  Then the denial.  It was a tough couple of years.

Bioshock?  Yeah, meh, I dunno, I liked it, don’t get me wrong, but although it was a beautifully rendered setting and the deco styling and all was very cool, I found it was a bit of a mediocre and rather claustrophobic shooter under the skin, and from all the hype I’d been expecting all kinds of clever moral choices and character advancement, and didn’t really find much of the sort.  You make a good point, actually, about the paucity of games with any kind of genuine moral depth.  I remember when Black & White was hailed as a revolution in gaming, a god-game in which the world would supposedly alter to reflect YOUR personality.  It bore the tagline, “find out who you are”.  But when it came down to it the only real option seemed to be a simple choice between “very bored” and “extremely bored”.  Fable and its sequels, though good games, are others in which I don’t necessarily feel the moral depth.  Likewise inFamous, which I’ve been playing recently, gives you the opportunity to run the entire moral spectrum from really evil to really good, with none of the stages in between, although at least it doesn’t lay claim to any particular sophistication.

Ironically, those games that trumpet their moral complexity often seem to be the simplest of all, and often are the least flexible plot-wise.  Maybe it’s the attempts to somehow ‘quantify’ morality, to reward it or not reward it.  I find the morality is often more interesting in games that are much more open-ended.  You mention Fallout 3.  I was a big fan of the original Fallout games way back in the 17th century and, not being a huge fan of Oblivion (I like it, but find certain elements execrable), I was watching through one eye to see how Bethesda Studios messed up a really innovative and interesting (though long-dead) franchise.  I thought they succeeded brilliantly, and blogged about it at tedious length.  Hugely varied, hugely atmospheric, and with a good sense of humour too (almost as rare in computer games as it is in American fantasy authors - Zing!)

Morgan’s question about what one would like to write a tie-in for brought to mind a game I left out - Thief.  Surely one of the most atmospheric and scary of all first-person games, with a superbly dark and rich fantasy world, and probably the most successful sneaking game ever done.  Stealth in computer games, like morality, is often talked up but very rarely done well…

Related posts:

• Computer Game Stories
  Ah, Brent, Brent, Brent.  Your parting shots remind me of someone.  Who is it?  Ah, yes, it’s this guy, on the canvas. But let us set aside our differences (particularly the massive difference between my amazing arguing ability and your frankly quite poor one) and concentrate instead on computer games. ...
• Best Video Game Stories Ever
  Brent and Joe discuss which video games have the best stories....
• Are you game?
  Video game novels are trendy. Warcraft, Halo, Gear of War & Bioshock are games with novel tie-ins out or coming soon. So, Brent & Joe, to hypothetically assume the luxury of spare time, is there any franchise out there for which you’d want to write a novel? Or, even better…...
• On Mortals’ Praises and Genii’s Duties
  Brent Weeks shows his clear rhetorical dominance over Joe Abercrombie. Again....
• Destroying you briefly
  I have been asked to reduce the size of my posts, therefore I shall destroy you briefly. Talk about frakking straw-men, it seems you’ve now taken to arguing with Neil Gaiman who, last time I checked, was not involved in this grudge match.  You obviously DARE NOT RESPOND TO MY...